Health and Social Care Committee
High confidence
On community mental health and crisis-pathway transformation: the Committee's December 2025 report called the Government's approach a 'golden opportunity' at risk of being missed and pressed for continued funding of six 24/7 Neighbourhood Mental Health Centre pilots; in March 2026 the Chair publicly described the Government response as 'disappointing' and was 'baffled' by the absence of national waiting-time standards.Dec 2025Mar 2026
Tension with Department of Health and Social Care, Wes Streeting
Department of Health and Social Care
High confidence
Bill sponsor; the November 2024 Impact Assessment presents Option 2 (full reform package) as preferred over business-as-usual despite a -£169m central NPV, on the strength of non-monetised patient-experience, racial-disparity and learning-disability/autism benefits.
Tension with Health and Social Care Committee
Wes Streeting
Medium confidence
Then Secretary of State who carried the Bill through Royal Assent; HCWS66 (Sept 2024) treated the Nottinghamshire CQC s.48 review as part of a broader reform commitment, and the Government chose not to adopt the HSCC's national waiting-time standards in its response.Sep 2024Mar 2026
Tension with Health and Social Care Committee
Care Quality Commission
High confidence
As statutory monitor the CQC has consistently flagged rising detention rates, racial disparities and ward-level practice failures (annual Monitoring the Mental Health Act reports 2013-14 through 2024-25); its s.48 review of Nottinghamshire Healthcare was the high-salience case study during Bill passage.Jan 2026Feb 2020Sep 2024
Royal College of Psychiatrists
Medium confidence
On the Bill's clinical mechanics: submitted PBC evidence supporting the patient-choice limb (ACDs, IMHAs, nominated persons) but with concerns on learning disability and autism detention scope and on workforce capacity to deliver the additional clinical activity.
Mind
Medium confidence
Supports the reform package as advancing patient autonomy and reducing inappropriate detention but pressed (further submission MHB36 was added in June 2025) for stronger statutory safeguards — the Commons amendments strengthening s.45 ACD arrangements track its line.
Professor Alex Ruck Keene KC (Hon)
Medium confidence
On the MCA/MHA interface and conditional discharge subject to deprivation-of-liberty conditions (s.35): warned the Bill's machinery has unresolved interaction with the Mental Capacity Act framework that risks litigation.
NHS Race and Health Observatory
Medium confidence
Submitted PBC evidence pressing for stronger statutory mechanisms to address the documented racial disparities in detention and CTO use — POSTnote 671 records that Black people are detained at four times the rate of white people.May 2022
Michael Brown OBE
Medium confidence
On s.135/136 reform and the police-mental health interface: submitted PBC evidence supporting removal of police stations as places of safety but flagging operational risk if health-based alternatives are not in place at commencement.
Stephen Kinnock
Medium confidence
Commons Bill minister; wrote multiple follow-up letters to MPs during PBC addressing devolved powers, IMHA concerns, tribunal powers, capacity and readmission data — engagement consistent with the Government's settled support for the package.
Baroness Merron
Medium confidence
Lords Bill minister; wrote successive peers' letters during Committee on CTOs, IMHAs, children and young people, county courts and legal aid — Government line was to defend the package and resist amendments inconsistent with the IA's design assumptions.
Sajid Javid
Medium confidence
Then Secretary of State who took the policy decision to legislate (HLWS185, July 2021 publishing the consultation response) — fixing the substantive reform package the 2025 Act subsequently enacted.Jul 2021
Victoria Atkins
Medium confidence
Then Secretary of State who commissioned the CQC s.48 review of Nottinghamshire Healthcare in January 2024 (reported via HCWS391, March 2024) — operational scrutiny of acute mental health provision in parallel with the legislative track.Mar 2024